The government steps in
To tackle this growing pile of waste – much of which has traditionally ended up in landfills – the Indian government has issued two directives:
- Guidelines on Usage of Refuse Derived Fuel in Various Industries
Central Public Health and Environmental Engineering Organisation; Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (Sep’ 2018).³
- Guideline Document Uniform Framework for Extended Producers Responsibility
Under Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016; Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (Jun’ 2020)
The first of these – which is now in force – aims to prevent the landfill of waste that are “combustible in nature but are not recyclable such as soiled paper, soiled cloth, contaminated plastics, multi-layer packaging materials, other packaging materials, pieces of leather, rubber, tyre, polystyrene, wood, etc.”. The second of – which is still in consultation stage – deals with plastic waste. Among other things, it will make companies that use plastic packaging for their products responsible for collecting and disposing of that packaging.⁴ One solution to both of these challenges is the substitution of fossil fuels by alternative refuse-derived fuels (RFD) at cement plants and thermal power plants.
The use of waste as an alternative fuel in the cement industry has a longstanding history, particularly in Europe, where substitution rates can reach well over 50% and companies are pushing to reach 100%. This is supported by generous gate fees paid by waste producers to cement companies and tight carbon emissions regulations (some alternative fuels are considered carbon neutral under EU regulations). Indeed, the use of RDF and other alternative fuels is acknowledged as a key step in the cement industry’s path to carbon neutrality, alongside energy efficiency and the use of supplementary cementitious materials.⁵
RDF in IndiaThe Cement Manufacturers Association (CMA) had expressed its commitment towards disposal of wastes and plastics and use of alternate fuels and raw materials.⁶
“…the Indian cement industry has been able to use almost 75 million tonnes of waste as a replacement of raw materials and fuels”.
As part of the new guidelines, cement companies are now required to utilise RDF in any kiln located within 400 km of an RDF production facility. Unusually, it is also the cement companies that are required to bear the cost of this rule, for example; there are no gate fees payable for taking waste and cement companies have to pay the transportation fees for the first 100 km radius of the plant.
The regulation envisages a rising scale of substitution rate from 6% in the first year up to 15% in the third year, although an evaluation of the amount of available RDF vs the energy needs of the cement industry suggest that a thermal substitution rate of 7.1% may be the maximum achievable (Table 1).
The data captures the details of daily exposed garbage. There is a significant quantum of legacy wastes which needs to be processed to make it usable RDF.
Table 1. Evaluation Of Possible Thermal Substitution Rate At Indian Cement Plants (RDF/Day)
|Number of cement plants in India||560*||Forecast by 2025 (550 - 600 million tpa)
|Large cement plants (>5000 tpd)||210*|
|Mini plants (5000 tpd)||350*|
|Total production of cement||575 million tpa|
|Total clinker production (India)
||431.25 million tpa||75% of total cement production|
|1.31 million tpd||330 running days|
|Heat Consumption (HC)||725 kCal/kg||Recurring figure|
|HC for total clinker production||947,443,181,818 kCal||HC*clinker production in kg|
|Total solid waste generation||0.15 million tpd**||Recurring figure|
|Total waste collected||0.135 million tpd**|
|Total waste processed||0.027 million tpd**|
|Average Net calorific value (NCV)||2500 kCal|
|Total energy content||67,500,000,000 kCal/day||Total waste*Average NCV|
|Possible substitution rate||7.1%||HC to total clinker production/total energy content|
A partner for sustainable waste management
The new regulations position the cement industry as a key partner in solving India’s waste challenges. However, there are certain challenges in its processing. Notably, the quality of RDF currently produced in India is much lower than that of in other regions, with lower calorific value and much higher moisture content.
The requirement for Indian cement companies to finance the CAPEX required to begin using RDF has also focused the market on economically viable, simple and standard alternative fuels feeding systems to meet the possible substitution rate up to 7%.
Going forward, to increase substitution rates, the cement industry needs accuracy in feeding and dosing system, efficient process and alternative fuel material analysis. To support these requirements, cement industry demands proven technologies like; rotor weighfeeders, a HOTDISC® Combustion Device, chlorine gas by-pass system and utilization of chlorine rich dust.
One exception to this (as mentioned above) is Dalmia Cement, which targets higher levels of alternative fuel substitution rates, reportedly up to 100%, as part of a corporate ambition to manufacture the greenest cement in the world.⁷ FLSmidth is supporting this ambition as the supplier of Dalmia Cement’s new plant at Rajgangpur, where the equipment and design of the plant were carefully selected to maximise the potential for alternative fuels and raw materials use, as well as to reduce energy efficiency and heat loss.
Plastic waste has garnered recent attention due to littering of crucial ecosystems, most notably that of oceans. According to one estimate, between 4.8 million tonnes and 12.7 million tonnes of plastic waste enters the oceans each year⁸. Reversing this damaging pattern has been recognised as integral to sustainable development and is a key target of the fourteenth UN Sustainable Development Goal.⁹
As part of the solution to this challenge, the Indian government has introduced rules that make use and disposal of plastic packaging as the responsibility of the generator. This impacts the Indian cement industry in a couple of different ways. Firstly, as a user of plastic packaging for its products – and with bagged cement playing a larger role in the Indian cement market than in other regions – the industry is faced with the need to set up systems to collect that plastic or switch to alternative paper-based packaging.
But the industry may also find itself (again) as a crucial part of the solution, due to its ability to utilise plastic waste as an alternative fuel. One opportunity arising from the regulations may be for the cement industry to partner with others that use plastic packaging to create efficient collection and processing systems for plastic waste that sees the non-recyclable elements made available for use in cement kilns.
Waste is a serious challenge to sustainable development. Finding ways to use the non-recyclable elements in a productive way is therefore key to setting humanity on a path to a cleaner, greener future. With its huge capacity to utilize RDF, the cement industry has a vital role in doing this. And the benefits of doing so reach far beyond (emptier) landfills. RDF substitution of fossil fuels reduces both the cement industry’s carbon emissions, as well as the necessity to mine fossil fuels.
Supporting the use of alternative fuels is therefore a priority for FLSmidth through our MissionZero ambitions to enable zero-emissions cement production. As part of this, we have committed to providing cement producers the solutions needed to operate with 100% alternative fuels. This goes beyond the provision of equipment to include our significant process experience – from initial reception and handling of alternative fuels through their impact on conditions in the kiln and on the final chemistry of cement. This deep understanding of the process enables us to assist any plant in solving the challenges that alternative fuels bring – whether just starting out or reaching for 100%.
This article was first published in International Cement Review, November 2020
1. KUMAR, S., et at., 2017, “Challenges and opportunities associated with waste management in India”, R. Society open sci.
2. AGGARWAL, M., 2019, “Mumbai and Delhi generate most solid waste among metro cities”, The Wire.
3. Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, 2018, Guidelines on Usage of Refuse Derived Fuels in Various Industries, p. X.
4. This principal is known as ‘Extended Producer Responsibility’.
5. For example, see: IEA, 2018, Technology Roadmap: Low-Carbon Transition in the Cement Industry, p. 28.
7. Global Cemfuels, 2019, “Dalmia Cement commits itself to 100% RDF and biofuels by 2030”.
8. JAMBECK, J.R., et al., (2015) “Plastic waste inputs from land into ocean”, Science vol. 347, issue 6223, pp. 768-771.